Repeating a year/retention

California study finds harm for some in repeating algebra, questions whether it benefits anyone

One of the most often repeated courses in U.S. high schools is algebra. Teachers and school leaders understandably worry whether a student who can’t solve basic equations should move on in math, to geometry or advanced algebra. So the student takes algebra again. Sometimes, even students with B’s in algebra are asked to repeat it […]

PERMALINK   |   Comments Off on California study finds harm for some in repeating algebra, questions whether it benefits anyone


New research suggests repeating elementary school grades — even kindergarten — is harmful

The already muddy research on whether it’s better to hold back struggling students or promote them to the next grade just got muddier. A new study ,“The Scarring Effects of Primary-Grade Retention? A Study of Cumulative Advantage in the Educational Career,” by Notre Dame sociologist Megan Andrew, published Sept. 26, 2014, in the journal Social Forces is […]

PERMALINK   |   Comments Off on New research suggests repeating elementary school grades — even kindergarten — is harmful


India data show test scores rise when students are automatically promoted to the next grade

A controversial 2009 law in India outlawed the practice of holding failing students back and making them repeat the entire year of school in classes 1 through 8. In India, it’s called “detention” and at least one student union staged a  protest this Spring to bring detention back, arguing that automatic promotion undermines academic quality […]

PERMALINK   |   Comments Off on India data show test scores rise when students are automatically promoted to the next grade